Home

Awesome

Scene Text Detection Resources

<p align='right'>Author: Chongyu Liu</p> <!-- MarkdownTOC -->

Updates

Dec 4, 2020: Add 2 papers from CVPR2020/ECCV2020 and update corresponding tables.

<!-- /MarkdownTOC -->
<!-- /MarkdownTOC -->

<a id="1-datasets"></a>

1. Datasets

<a id="11-Horizontal-Text-Datasets"></a>

1.1 Horizontal-Text Datasets

<a id="12-Arbitrary-Quadrilateral-Text-Datasets"></a>

1.2 Arbitrary-Quadrilateral-Text Datasets

<a id="13-Irregular-Text-Datasets"></a>

1.3 Irregular-Text Datasets

<a id="14-synthetic-datasets"></a>

1.4 Synthetic Datasets

<a id="15-comparison-of-datasets"></a>

1.5 Comparison of Datasets

<body> <table cellspacing="0" border="0"> <colgroup width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="119"></colgroup> <colgroup span="7" width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="153"></colgroup> <colgroup width="104"></colgroup> <colgroup span="3" width="85"></colgroup> <tr> <td colspan=14 height="20" align="center"><b>Comparison of Datasets</b></td> </tr> <tr> <td rowspan=2 height="39" align="center" valign=top><b>Datasets</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=top><b>Language</b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center"><b>Image</b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center"><b>Text instance </b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center"><b>Text Shape</b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center"><b>Annotation level</b></td> </tr> <tr> <td align="center"><b>Total</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Train</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Test</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Total</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Train</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Test</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Horizontal</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Arbitrary-Quadrilateral</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Multi-oriented</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Char</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Word</b></td> <td align="center"><b>Text-Line</b></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>IC03</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center" sdval="509" sdnum="2052;">509</td> <td align="center" sdval="258" sdnum="2052;">258</td> <td align="center" sdval="251" sdnum="2052;">251</td> <td align="center" sdval="2266" sdnum="2052;">2266</td> <td align="center" sdval="1110" sdnum="2052;">1110</td> <td align="center" sdval="1156" sdnum="2052;">1156</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>IC11</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center" sdval="484" sdnum="2052;">484</td> <td align="center" sdval="229" sdnum="2052;">229</td> <td align="center" sdval="255" sdnum="2052;">255</td> <td align="center" sdval="1564" sdnum="2052;">1564</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>IC13</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center" sdval="462" sdnum="2052;">462</td> <td align="center" sdval="229" sdnum="2052;">229</td> <td align="center" sdval="233" sdnum="2052;">233</td> <td align="center" sdval="1944" sdnum="2052;">1944</td> <td align="center" sdval="849" sdnum="2052;">849</td> <td align="center" sdval="1095" sdnum="2052;">1095</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>USTB-SV1K</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center" sdval="1000" sdnum="2052;">1000</td> <td align="center" sdval="500" sdnum="2052;">500</td> <td align="center" sdval="500" sdnum="2052;">500</td> <td align="center" sdval="2955" sdnum="2052;">2955</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>SVT</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center" sdval="350" sdnum="2052;">350</td> <td align="center" sdval="100" sdnum="2052;">100</td> <td align="center" sdval="250" sdnum="2052;">250</td> <td align="center" sdval="725" sdnum="2052;">725</td> <td align="center" sdval="211" sdnum="2052;">211</td> <td align="center" sdval="514" sdnum="2052;">514</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>SVT-P</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center" sdval="238" sdnum="2052;">238</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center" sdval="639" sdnum="2052;">639</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>IC15</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center" sdval="1500" sdnum="2052;">1500</td> <td align="center" sdval="1000" sdnum="2052;">1000</td> <td align="center" sdval="500" sdnum="2052;">500</td> <td align="center" sdval="17548" sdnum="2052;">17548</td> <td align="center" sdval="122318" sdnum="2052;">122318</td> <td align="center" sdval="5230" sdnum="2052;">5230</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>COCO-Text</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center" sdval="63686" sdnum="2052;">63686</td> <td align="center" sdval="43686" sdnum="2052;">43686</td> <td align="center" sdval="20000" sdnum="2052;">20000</td> <td align="center" sdval="145859" sdnum="2052;">145859</td> <td align="center" sdval="118309" sdnum="2052;">118309</td> <td align="center" sdval="27550" sdnum="2052;">27550</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>MSRA-TD500</b></td> <td align="center">English/Chinese</td> <td align="center" sdval="500" sdnum="2052;">500</td> <td align="center" sdval="300" sdnum="2052;">300</td> <td align="center" sdval="200" sdnum="2052;">200</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>MLT 2017</b></td> <td align="center">Multi-lingual</td> <td align="center" sdval="18000" sdnum="2052;">18000</td> <td align="center" sdval="7200" sdnum="2052;">7200</td> <td align="center" sdval="10800" sdnum="2052;">10800</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>MLT 2019</b></td> <td align="center">Multi-lingual</td> <td align="center" sdval="20000" sdnum="2052;">20000</td> <td align="center" sdval="10000" sdnum="2052;">10000</td> <td align="center" sdval="10000" sdnum="2052;">10000</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>CTW</b></td> <td align="center">Chinese</td> <td align="center" sdval="32285" sdnum="2052;">32285</td> <td align="center" sdval="25887" sdnum="2052;">25887</td> <td align="center" sdval="6398" sdnum="2052;">6398</td> <td align="center" sdval="1018402" sdnum="2052;">1018402</td> <td align="center" sdval="812872" sdnum="2052;">812872</td> <td align="center" sdval="205530" sdnum="2052;">205530</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>RCTW-17</b></td> <td align="center">English/Chinese</td> <td align="center" sdval="12514" sdnum="2052;">12514</td> <td align="center" sdval="15114" sdnum="2052;">15114</td> <td align="center" sdval="1000" sdnum="2052;">1000</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>ReCTS</b></td> <td align="center">Chinese</td> <td align="center" sdval="20000" sdnum="2052;">20000</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>CUTE80</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center" sdval="80" sdnum="2052;">80</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>Total-Text</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center" sdval="1525" sdnum="2052;">1525</td> <td align="center" sdval="1225" sdnum="2052;">1225</td> <td align="center" sdval="300" sdnum="2052;">300</td> <td align="center" sdval="9330" sdnum="2052;">9330</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>CTW-1500</b></td> <td align="center">English/Chinese</td> <td align="center" sdval="1500" sdnum="2052;">1500</td> <td align="center" sdval="1000" sdnum="2052;">1000</td> <td align="center" sdval="500" sdnum="2052;">500</td> <td align="center" sdval="10751" sdnum="2052;">10751</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>LSVT</b></td> <td align="center">English/Chinese</td> <td align="center" sdval="450000" sdnum="2052;">450000</td> <td align="center" sdval="430000" sdnum="2052;">430000</td> <td align="center" sdval="20000" sdnum="2052;">20000</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>ArT</b></td> <td align="center">English/Chinese</td> <td align="center" sdval="450000" sdnum="2052;">10166</td> <td align="center" sdval="430000" sdnum="2052;">5603</td> <td align="center" sdval="20000" sdnum="2052;">4563</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>Synth80k</b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center">80k</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">8m</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b>SynthText </b></td> <td align="center">English</td> <td align="center">800k</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">6m</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">~</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> </tr> </table>

<a id="2-summary-of-scene-text-detection-results"></a>

2. Summary of Scene Text Detection Resources

<a id="21-comparison-of-methods"></a>

2.1 Comparison of Methods

Scene text detection methods can be devided into four parts:

(a) Traditional methods;

(b) Segmentation-based methods;

(c) Regression-based methods;

(d) Hybrid methods.

It is important to notice that: (1) "Hori" stands for horizontal scene text datasets. (2) "Quad" stands for arbitrary-quadrilateral-text datasets. (3) "Irreg" stands for irregular scence text datasets. (4) "Traditional method" stands for the methods that don't rely on deep learning.

<a id="#211-traditional-methods"></a>

2.1.1 Traditional Methods

<table cellspacing="0" border="0"> <colgroup width="106"></colgroup> <colgroup span="7" width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="807"></colgroup> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Method&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Model&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Code</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Hori</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Quad</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Irreg</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Source </font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Time</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Highlight&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yao et al. [1]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TD-Mixture</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2012</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">1) A new dataset MSRA-TD500 and protocol for evaluation. 2) Equipped a two-level classification scheme and two sets of features extractor.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yin et al. [2]</font></td> <td align="center"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TPAMI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2013</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Extract Maximally Stable Extremal Regions (MSERs) as character candidates and group them together.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Le et al. [5]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">HOCC</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2014</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">HOCC + MSERs</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yin et al. [7]</font></td> <td align="center"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TPAMI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Presenting a unified distance metric learning framework for adaptive hierarchical clustering.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wu et al. [9]</font></td> <td align="center"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Exploring gradient directional symmetry at component level for smoothing edge components before text detection. </font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [17]</font></td> <td align="center"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Scene text is first detected locally in individual frames and finally linked by an optimal tracking trajectory.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yang et al. [33]</font></td> <td align="center" valign=middle><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">A text detector will locate character candidates and extract text regions. Then they will linked by an optimal tracking trajectory.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">Liang et al. [8]</font></td> <td align="center"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Exploring maxima stable extreme regions along with stroke width transform for detecting candidate text regions.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">Michal et al.[12]</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">FASText</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="center">✓</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="center">✕</td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Stroke keypoints are efficiently detected and then exploited to obtain stroke segmentations.</font></td> </tr> </table>

<a id="212-Pixel-level-methods"></a>

2.1.2 Segmentation-based Methods

<table cellspacing="0" border="0"> <colgroup width="147"></colgroup> <colgroup span="7" width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="633"></colgroup> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Method&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Model&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Code</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Hori</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Quad</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Irreg</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Source </font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Time</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Highlight&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Li et al. [3]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2014</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">(1)develop three novel cues that are tailored for character detection and a Bayesian method for their integration; (2)design a Markov random field model to exploit the inherent dependencies between characters.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhang et al. [14]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Utilizing FCN for salient map detection and centroid of each character prediction.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhu et al. [16]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Performs a graph-based segmentation of connected components into words (Word-Graph).</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [18]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Text-CNN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Developing a new learning mechanism to train the Text-CNN with multi-level and rich supervised information.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yao et al. [21]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing to localize text in a holistic manner, by casting scene text detection as a semantic segmentation problem.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Hu et al. [27]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">WordSup</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a weakly supervised framework that can utilize word annotations. Then the detected characters are fed to a text structure analysis module.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wu et al. [28]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Introducing the border class to the text detection problem for the first time, and validate that the decoding process is largely simplified with the help of text border.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tang et al.[32]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">A text-aware candidate text region(CTR) extraction model + CTR refinement model.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Dai et al. [35]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FTSN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Detecting and segmenting the text instance jointly and simultaneously, leveraging merits from both semantic segmentation task and region proposal based object detection task.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [38]</font></td> <td align="left" valign=middle><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICDAR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">This paper proposes a novel character candidate extraction method based on super-pixel segmentation and hierarchical clustering.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Deng et al. [40]</font></td> <td align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PixelLink</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Text instances are first segmented out by linking pixels wthin the same instance together.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [42]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">MCN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Stochastic Flow Graph (SFG) + Markov Clustering.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Lyu et al. [43]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Detect scene text by localizing corner points of text bounding boxes and segmenting text regions in relative positions.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Chu et al. [45]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Border</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">The paper presents a novel scene text detection technique that makes use of semantics-aware text borders and bootstrapping based text segment augmentation.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Long et al. [46]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextSnake</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">The paper proposes TextSnake, which is able to effectively represent text instances in horizontal, oriented and curved forms based on symmetry axis.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yang et al. [47]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IncepText</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Designing a novel Inception-Text module and introduce deformable PSROI pooling to deal with multi-oriented text detection.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yue et al. [48]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">BMVC</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a general framework for text detection called Guided CNN to achieve the two goals simultaneously.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhong et al. [53]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AF-RPN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Presenting AF-RPN(anchor-free) as an anchor-free and scale-friendly region proposal network for the Faster R-CNN framework.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [54]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PSENet</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a novel Progressive Scale Expansion Network (PSENet), designed as a segmentation-based detector with multiple predictions for each text instance.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Xu et al.[57]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextField</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Presenting a novel direction field which can represent scene texts of arbitrary shapes.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [58]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FTDN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FTDN is able to segment text region and simultaneously regress text box at pixel-level.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [83]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Constraining embedding feature of pixels inside the same text region to share similar properties.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Huang et al. [4]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">MSERs-CNN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2014</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Combining MSERs with CNN</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Sun et al. [6]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Presenting a robust text detection approach based on color-enhanced CER and neural networks.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Baek et al. [62]</font></td> <td align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CRAFT</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Proposing CRAFT effectively detect text area by exploring each character and affinity between characters.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Richardson et al. [87]</td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left">WACV</td> <td align="left" sdval="2020" sdnum="2052;">2019</td> <td align="left">Presenting an additional scale predictor the estimate the better scale of text regions for testing.</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al. [88]</td> <td align="left">SAST</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left">ACMM</td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;">2019</td> <td align="left">Presenting a context attended multi-task learning framework for scene text detection.</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al. [90]</td> <td align="left">PAN</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left">ICCV</td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;">2019</td> <td align="left">Proposing an efficient and accurate arbitrary-shaped text detector called Pixel Aggregation Network(PAN),</td> </tr> </table>

<a id="213-regression-methods"></a>

2.1.3 Regression-based Methods

<body> <table cellspacing="0" border="0"> <colgroup width="118"></colgroup> <colgroup span="7" width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="797"></colgroup> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Method&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Model&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Code</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Hori</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Quad</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Irreg</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Source </font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Time</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Highlight&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Gupta et al. [15]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FCRN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">(a) Proposing a fast and scalable engine to generate synthetic images of text in clutter; (b) FCRN. </font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhong et al. [20]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">DeepText</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">(a) Inception-RPN; (b) Utilize ambiguous text category (ATC) information and multilevel region-of-interest pooling (MLRP).</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liao et al. [22]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextBoxes</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Mainly basing SSD object detection framework.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [25]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">DMPNet</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Quadrilateral sliding windows + shared Monte-Carlo method for fast and accurate computing of the polygonal areas + a sequential protocol for relative regression.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [26]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">DDR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing an FCN that has bi-task outputs where one is pixel-wise classification between text and non-text, and the other is direct regression to determine the vertex coordinates of quadrilateral text boundaries.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Jiang et al. [36]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">R2CNN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Using the Region Proposal Network (RPN) to generate axis-aligned bounding boxes that enclose the texts with different orientations.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Xing et al. [37]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ArbiText</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Adopting the circle anchors and incorporating a pyramid pooling module into the Single Shot MultiBox Detector framework.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhang et al. [39]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FEN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a refined scene text detector with a novel Feature Enhancement Network (FEN) for Region Proposal and Text Detection Refinement.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [41]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ITN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ITN is presented to learn the geometry-aware representation encoding the unique geometric configurations of scene text instances with in-network transformation embedding.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liao et al. [44]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RRD</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">The regression branch extracts rotation-sensitive features, while the classification branch extracts rotation-invariant features by pooling the rotation sensitive features.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liao et al. [49]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextBoxes++</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Mainly basing SSD object detection framework and it replaces the rectangular box representation in conventional object detector by a quadrilateral or oriented rectangle representation.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [50]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a scene text detection framework based on fully convolutional network with a bi-task prediction module.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Ma et al. [51]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RRPN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RRPN + RRoI Pooling.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhu et al. [55]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SLPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SLPR regresses multiple points on the edge of text line and then utilizes these points to sketch the outlines of the text.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Deng et al. [56]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CRPN employs corners to estimate the possible locations of text instances. And it also designs a embedded data augmentation module inside region-wise subnetwork.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Cai et al. [59]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FFN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a Feature Fusion Network to deal with text regions differing in enormous sizes.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Sabyasachi et al. [60]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RGC</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a novel recurrent architecture to improve the learnings of a feature map at a given time.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [63]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CTD</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CTD + TLOC + PNMS</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Xie et al. [79]</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">DeRPN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">DeRPN utilizes anchor string mechanism instead of anchor box in RPN.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [82]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Text-RPN + RNN</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [84]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="left">CSE mechanism</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [29]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SSTD</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing an attention mechanism. Then developing a hierarchical inception module which efficiently aggregates multi-scale inception features.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [11]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Cascade boosting detects character candidates, and the min-cost flow network model get the final result.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [13]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CTPN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">1) RPN + LSTM. 2) RPN incorporate a new vertical anchor mechanism and LSTM connects the region to get the final result.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [19]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ACCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ER detetctor detects regions to get coarse prediction of text regions. Then the local context is aggregated to classify the remaining regions to obtain a final prediction.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Shi et al. [23]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SegLink</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Decomposing text into segments and links. A link connects two adjacent segments. </font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [30]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">WeText</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a weakly supervised scene text detection method (WeText).</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhu et al. [31]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RTN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICDAR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Mainly basing CTPN vertical vertical proposal mechanism.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Ren et al. [34]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a CNN-based detector. It contains a text structure component detector layer, a spatial pyramid layer, and a multi-input-layer deep belief network (DBN).</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhang et al. [10]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2015" sdnum="2052;">2015</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">The proposed algorithm exploits the symmetry property of character groups and allows for direct extraction of text lines from natural images.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al. [86]</td> <td align="left">DSRN</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left">IJCAI</td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;">2019</td> <td align="left">Presenting a scale-transfer module and scale relationship module to handle the problem of scale variation.</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Tang et al.[89]</td> <td align="left">Seglink++</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left">PR</td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;">2019</td> <td align="left">Presenting instance aware component grouping (ICG) for arbitrary-shape text detection.</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al.[92]</td> <td align="left">ContourNet</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left">CVPR</td> <td align="left" sdval="2020" sdnum="2052;">2020</td> <td align="left">1.A scale-insensitive Adaptive Region Proposal Network (AdaptiveRPN); 2. Local Orthogonal Texture-aware Module (LOTM).</td> </tr> </table> </body>

<a id="214-hybrid-methods"></a>

2.1.4 Hybrid Methods

<body> <table cellspacing="0" border="0"> <colgroup width="118"></colgroup> <colgroup width="135"></colgroup> <colgroup span="6" width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="516"></colgroup> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Method&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Model&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Code</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Hori</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Quad</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Irreg</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Source </font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">Time</font></b></td> <td align="center"><b><font face="Arial">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Highlight&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tang et al. [52]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SSFT</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a novel scene text detection method that involves superpixel-based stroke feature transform (SSFT) and deep learning based region classification (DLRC).</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Xie et al.[61]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SPCNet</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Text Context module + Re-Score mechanism.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [64]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PMTD</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Perform “soft” semantic segmentation. It assigns a soft pyramid label (i.e., a real value between 0 and 1) for each pixel within text instance.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [80]</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">BDN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">Discretizing bouding boxes into key edges to address label confusion for text detection.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Zhang et al. [81]</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">LOMO</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">DR + IRM + SEM</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Zhou et al. [24]</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">EAST</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">2017</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">The pipeline directly predicts words or text lines of arbitrary orientations and quadrilateral shapes in full images with instance segmentation.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yue et al. [48]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">BMVC</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Proposing a general framework for text detection called Guided CNN to achieve the two goals simultaneously.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhong et al. [53]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AF-RPN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td colspan=13 align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Presenting AF-RPN(anchor-free) as an anchor-free and scale-friendly region proposal network for the Faster R-CNN framework.</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Xue et al.[85]</td> <td align="left">MSR</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left">IJCAI</td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;">2019</td> <td align="left">Presenting a noval multi-scale regression network.</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Liao et al. [91]</td> <td align="left">DB</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left">AAAI</td> <td align="left" sdval="2020" sdnum="2052;">2020</td> <td align="left">Presenting differentiable binarization module to adaptively set the thresholds for binarization, which simplifies the post-processing.</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Xiao et al. [93]</td> <td align="left">SDM</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✕</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@">✓</td> <td align="left">ECCV</td> <td align="left" sdval="2020" sdnum="2052;">2020</td> <td align="left">1. A novel sequential deformation method; 2. auxiliary character counting supervision.</td> </tr> </table> <!-- ************************************************************************** --> </body>

<a id="22-detection-result"></a>

2.2 Detection Results

<a id="221-Detection-Results-on-Horizontal-Text-Datasets"></a>

2.2.1 Detection Results on Horizontal-Text Datasets

<body> <table cellspacing="0" border="0"> <colgroup width="192"></colgroup> <colgroup span="3" width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="161"></colgroup> <colgroup span="9" width="85"></colgroup> <tr> <td rowspan=2 height="39" align="center" valign=middle><b>Method&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Model</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Source</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Time</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Method Category</b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">IC11[68]</font></b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">IC13 [69]</font></b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">IC05[67]</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yao et al. [1]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TD-Mixture</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2012</font></td> <td rowspan=6 align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Traditional </font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.69</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.66</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.67</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yin et al. [2]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TPAMI</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2013</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.68</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.76</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yin et al. [7]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TPAMI</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.838</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.66</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.738</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wu et al. [9]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.76</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.70</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.73</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liang et al. [8]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.77</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.68</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.71</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.76</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.68</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.72</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Michal et al.[12]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FASText</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.84</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.69</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.77</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Li et al. [3]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2014</font></td> <td rowspan=14 align="left" valign=middle>Segmentation</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.62</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.70</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhang et al. [14]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.78</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [18]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Text-CNN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.91</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.74</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.82</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.93</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.73</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.82</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.87</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.73</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.79</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yao et al. [21]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.889</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.802</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.843</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Hu et al. [27]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">WordSup</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.933</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.875</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.903</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tang et al.[32]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.90</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.92</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.87</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [38]</font></td> <td align="left" valign=middle><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICDAR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.87</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.78</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.82</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.87</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.82</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.84</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Deng et al. [40]</font></td> <td align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PixelLink</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.886</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.875</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.881</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [42]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">MCN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.87</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Lyu et al. [43]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.92</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.844</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.880</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Chu et al. [45]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Border</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.915</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.871</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.892</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [54]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PSENet</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.94</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.90</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.92</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Huang et al. [4]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">MSERs-CNN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2014</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.71</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.78</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.84</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.67</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.75</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Sun et al. [6]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.92</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.91</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.91</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.94</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.92</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.93</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Gupta et al. [15]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FCRN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td rowspan=24 align="left" valign=middle>Regression</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.94</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.77</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.85</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.938</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.764</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.842</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhong et al. [20]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">DeepText</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.87</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.85</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.85</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liao et al. [22]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextBoxes</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.82</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [25]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">DMPNet</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.93</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.870</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Jiang et al. [36]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">R2CNN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.92</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Xing et al. [37]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ArbiText</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.826</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.936</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.877</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [41]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ITN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.896</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.889</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.892</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.941</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.893</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.916</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liao et al. [49]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextBoxes++</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.92</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [50]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.91</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.84</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Ma et al. [51]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RRPN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.95</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.91</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhu et al. [55]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SLPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.90</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.72</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Cai et al. [59]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FFN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.92</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.84</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Sabyasachi et al. [60]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RGC</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICIP</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.77</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [82]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.937" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.937</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.878" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.878</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.907" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.907</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [84]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.937" sdnum="2052;">0.937</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.897" sdnum="2052;">0.897</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.917" sdnum="2052;">0.917</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [29]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SSTD</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [11]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.76</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.852</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.759</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.802</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [13]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CTPN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.93</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [19]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ACCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.90</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.75</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Shi et al. [23]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SegLink</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.877</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.853</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [30]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">WeText</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.911</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.831</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.869</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhu et al. [31]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RTN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICDAR</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.94</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.91</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Ren et al. [34]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.78</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.67</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.72</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.67</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.73</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhang et al. [10]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2015" sdnum="2052;">2015</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.84</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.76</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.74</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tang et al. [52]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SSFT</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td rowspan=7 align="left" valign=middle>Hybrid</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.906</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.847</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.911</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.861</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.885</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Xie et al.[61]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SPCNet</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.94</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.91</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.92</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [80]</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">BDN</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.887</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.894</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Zhou et al. [24]</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">EAST</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.93</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.870</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yue et al. [48]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">BMVC</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.885</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.846</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.870</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhong et al. [53]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AF-RPN</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.94</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.90</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.92</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Xue et al.[85]</td> <td align="left">MSR</td> <td align="left">IJCAI</td> <td align="left" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;">2019</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.918</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.885</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.901</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> </table>

<a id="222-Detection-Results-on-Arbitrary-Quadrilateral-Text-Datasets"></a>

2.2.2 Detection Results on Arbitrary-Quadrilateral-Text Datasets

<body> <table cellspacing="0" border="0"> <colgroup width="147"></colgroup> <colgroup span="3" width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="129"></colgroup> <colgroup span="7" width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="141"></colgroup> <colgroup span="4" width="85"></colgroup> <tr> <td rowspan=2 height="39" align="center" valign=middle><b><font face="Arial">Method&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b><font face="Arial">Model</font></b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Source</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Time</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Method Category</b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">IC15 [70]</font></b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">MSRA-TD500 [71]</font></b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">USTB-SV1K [65]</font></b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">SVT [66]</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Le et al. [5]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">HOCC</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2014</font></td> <td rowspan=6 align="center" valign=middle><font face="Arial">Traditional</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.71</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.62</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.66</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yin et al. [7]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TPAMI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.63</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.71</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.499</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.454</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.475</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wu et al. [9]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.63</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.70</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.66</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [17]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.95</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.58</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.721</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.537</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.488</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.51</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yang et al. [33]</font></td> <td align="left" valign=middle><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.95</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.58</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.72</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.54</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.49</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.51</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">Liang et al. [8]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2015</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.74</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.66</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.70</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhang et al. [14]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td rowspan=21 align="center" valign=middle><font face="Arial">Segmentation</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.71</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.43</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.54</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.67</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.74</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhu et al. [16]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.91</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.85</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [18]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Text-CNN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.76</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.61</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.69</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yao et al. [21]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.723</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.587</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.648</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.765</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.753</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.759</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Hu et al. [27]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">WordSup</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.793</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.77</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.782</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wu et al. [28]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.91</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.78</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.84</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.77</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.78</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.77</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Dai et al. [35]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FTSN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.886</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.841</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.771</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.82</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Deng et al. [40]</font></td> <td align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PixelLink</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.855</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.820</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.837</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.830</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.732</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.778</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [42]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">MCN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.72</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.76</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.79</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Lyu et al. [43]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.895</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.797</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.843</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.762</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.815</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Chu et al. [45]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Border</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.830</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.774</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.801</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Long et al. [46]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextSnake</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.849</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.804</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.826</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.832</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.739</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.783</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yang et al. [47]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IncepText</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.938</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.873</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.905</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.875</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.790</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.830</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [54]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PSENet</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.8692</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.845</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.8569</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Xu et al.[57]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextField</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.843</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.805</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.824</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.874</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.759</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.813</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [58]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FTDN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.847</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.773</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.809</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [83]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.883</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.850</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.866</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.842</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.817</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.829</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Baek et al. [62]</font></td> <td align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CRAFT</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.898</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.843</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.869</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.882</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.782</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.829</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Richardson et al. [87]</td> <td align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.853</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.827</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al. [88]</td> <td align="left">SAST</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ACMM</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.8755</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.8734</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.8744</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al. [90]</td> <td align="left">PAN</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.84</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.819</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.829</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.844</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.838</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.821</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Gupta et al. [15]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FCRN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td rowspan=21 align="center" valign=middle><font face="Arial">Regression</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.651</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.599</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.624</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [25]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">DMPNet</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.732</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.682</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.706</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [26]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">DDR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.82</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.77</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.70</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.74</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Jiang et al. [36]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">R2CNN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.856</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.797</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.825</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Xing et al. [37]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ArbiText</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.792</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.735</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.759</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.78</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.72</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.75</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [41]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ITN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.857</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.741</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.795</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.903</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.723</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.803</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liao et al. [44]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RRD</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.88</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.8</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.838</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.73</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.79</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liao et al. [49]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextBoxes++</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.878</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.785</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.829</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [50]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.85</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.82</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.91</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Ma et al. [51]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RRPN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.822</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.732</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.774</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.821</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.677</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.742</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhu et al. [55]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SLPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.855</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.836</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.845</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Deng et al. [56]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.845</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Sabyasachi et al. [60]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RGC</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.82</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.85</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.76</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [82]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.892" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.892</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.86" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.876" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.852" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.852</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.821" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.821</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.836" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.836</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [29]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SSTD</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.73</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.77</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tian et al. [13]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CTPN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.74</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.52</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.61</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [19]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ACCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.87</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.73</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.79</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Shi et al. [23]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SegLink</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.731</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.768</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.75</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.70</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.77</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al. [86]</td> <td align="left">DSRN</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.832</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.796</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.814</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.712</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.785</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Tang et al.[89]</td> <td align="left">Seglink++</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.837</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.803</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.820</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al. [92]</td> <td align="left">ContourNet</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2020</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.861</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.869</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Tang et al. [52]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SSFT</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td rowspan=11 align="center" valign=middle><font face="Arial">Hybrid</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.541</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.758</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.631</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Xie et al.[61]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SPCNet</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.87</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [64]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PMTD</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.913</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.874</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.893</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [80]</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">BDN</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.881</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.846</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.863</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.87</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.815</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.842</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Zhang et al. [81]</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">LOMO</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.878</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.877</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left"><font face="Arial">Zhou et al. [24]</font></td> <td align="left"><font face="Arial">EAST</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.833</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.783</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.807</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.873</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.674</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.761</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yue et al. [48]</font></td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">BMVC</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.866</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.789</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.823</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.691</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.660</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.675</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhong et al. [53]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AF-RPN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.89</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.86</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Xue et al.[85]</td> <td align="left">MSR</td> <td align="center">IJCAI</td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;">2019</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.874" sdnum="2052;">0.874</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.767" sdnum="2052;">0.767</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.817" sdnum="2052;">0.817</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Liao et al. [91]</td> <td align="left">DB</td> <td align="center">AAAI</td> <td align="center" sdval="2020" sdnum="2052;">2020</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.918" sdnum="2052;">0.918</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.832" sdnum="2052;">0.832</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.873" sdnum="2052;">0.873</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.915" sdnum="2052;">0.915</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.792" sdnum="2052;">0.792</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.849" sdnum="2052;">0.849</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Xiao et al. [93]</td> <td align="left">SDM</td> <td align="center">ECCV</td> <td align="center" sdval="2020" sdnum="2052;">2020</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.9196" sdnum="2052;">0.9196</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.8922" sdnum="2052;">0.8922</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.9057</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> </table> <!-- ************************************************************************** --> </body> <body> <table cellspacing="0" border="0"> <colgroup width="149"></colgroup> <colgroup width="110"></colgroup> <colgroup span="2" width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="153"></colgroup> <colgroup span="12" width="85"></colgroup> <tr> <td rowspan=2 height="39" align="center" valign=middle><b><font face="Arial">Method&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b><font face="Arial">Model</font></b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Source</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Time</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Method Category</b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">IC15 [70]</font></b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">MSRA-TD500 [71]</font></b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">USTB-SV1K [65]</font></b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">SVT [66]</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Le et al. [5]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">HOCC</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2014</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">Traditional</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.80</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.73</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.76</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yao et al. [21]</font></td> <td align="center"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td rowspan=7 align="center" valign=middle><font face="Arial">Segmentation</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.432</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.27</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.333</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Hu et al. [27]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">WordSup</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.452</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.309</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.368</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Lyu et al. [43]</font></td> <td align="center"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.351</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.348</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.349</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.743</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.706</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.724</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Chu et al. [45]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Border</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.782</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.588</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.671</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.777</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.621</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.690</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Yang et al. [47]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IncepText</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.785</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.569</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.660</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [54]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PSENet</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.7535</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.6918</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.7213</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Baek et al. [62]</font></td> <td align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CRAFT</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.806</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.682</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.739</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [29]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SSTD</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td rowspan=11 align="center" valign=middle><font face="Arial">Regression</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.46</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.31</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.37</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Gupta et al. [15]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FCRN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2016</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.844</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.763</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.801</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liao et al. [49]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextBoxes++</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.61</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.57</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.59</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Ma et al. [51]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RRPN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TMM</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.7669</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.5794</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.6601</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Deng et al. [56]</font></td> <td align="center"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.555</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.633</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.591</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Cai et al. [59]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">FFN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICIP</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.43</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.35</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.39</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><font face="Arial">Xie et al. [79]</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">DeRPN</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.586" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.586</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.557" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.557</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.571" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">0.571</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">He et al. [29]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SSTD</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.46</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.31</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.37</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liao et al. [44]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">RRD</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.591</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.775</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.670</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Richardson et al. [87]</td> <td align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><br></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.729</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.618</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.669</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center">Wang et al. [88]</td> <td align="center">SAST</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ACMM</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.7935</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.6653</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.7237</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Xie et al.[61]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SPCNet</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td rowspan=8 align="center" valign=middle><font face="Arial">Hybrid</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.806</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.686</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.741</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [64]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PMTD</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.844</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.763</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.801</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [80]</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">BDN</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">IJCAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.791</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.698</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.742</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><font face="Arial">Zhang et al. [81]</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">LOMO</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.791</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.602</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.684</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.802</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.672</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.731</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center"><font face="Arial">Zhou et al. [24]</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">EAST</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">2017</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.504</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.324</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.395</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhong et al. [53]</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AF-RPN</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.75</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.66</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.70</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center">Liao et al. [91]</td> <td align="center">DB</td> <td align="center">AAAI</td> <td align="center" sdval="2020" sdnum="2052;">2020</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.831" sdnum="2052;">0.831</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.679" sdnum="2052;">0.679</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.747" sdnum="2052;">0.747</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="center">Xiao et al. [93]</td> <td align="center">SDM</td> <td align="center">ECCV</td> <td align="center" sdval="2020" sdnum="2052;">2020</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.8679" sdnum="2052;">0.8679</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.7526" sdnum="2052;">0.7526</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.8061" sdnum="2052;">0.8061</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> </table> <!-- ************************************************************************** --> </body>

<a id="223-Detection-Results-on-Irregular-Text-Datasets"></a>

2.2.3 Detection Results on Irregular-Text Datasets

In this section, we only select those methods suitable for irregular text detection.

<body> <table cellspacing="0" border="0"> <colgroup width="111"></colgroup> <colgroup span="3" width="85"></colgroup> <colgroup width="185"></colgroup> <colgroup span="6" width="85"></colgroup> <tr> <td rowspan=2 height="39" align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">Method&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font></b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">Model</font></b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Source</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Time</b></td> <td rowspan=2 align="center" valign=middle><b>Method Category</b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">Total-text [74]</font></b></td> <td colspan=3 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">SCUT-CTW1500 [75]</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">P</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">R</font></b></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><b><font face="Arial">F</font></b></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Baek et al. [62]</font></td> <td align="left" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CRAFT</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td rowspan=6 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Segmentation</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.799</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.836</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.860</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.811</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.835</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Long et al. [46]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">TextSnake</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ECCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.827</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.745</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.784</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.679</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.853</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.756</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Tian et al. [83]</td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="81.7" sdnum="2052;">81.7</td> <td align="center" sdval="84.2" sdnum="2052;">84.2</td> <td align="center" sdval="80.1" sdnum="2052;">80.1</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [54]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PSENet</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.840</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.779</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.809</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.848</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.797</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.822</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Wang et al. [88]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SAST</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ACMM</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.8557</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.7549</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.802</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.8119</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.8171</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.8145</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al. [90]</td> <td align="left">PAN</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">ICCV</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.893</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.81</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.85</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.864</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.812</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.837</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Zhu et al. [55]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SLPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">arXiv</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2018</font></td> <td rowspan=6 align="center" valign=middle sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Regression</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.801</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.701</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.748</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Liu et al. [63]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CTD+TLOC</font></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">PR</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.774</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.698</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.734</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al. [82]</td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="80.1" sdnum="2052;">80.1</td> <td align="center" sdval="80.2" sdnum="2052;">80.2</td> <td align="center" sdval="80.1" sdnum="2052;">80.1</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Liu et al. [84]</td> <td align="left"><br></td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.814" sdnum="2052;">0.814</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.791" sdnum="2052;">0.791</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.802" sdnum="2052;">0.802</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.787" sdnum="2052;">0.787</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.761" sdnum="2052;">0.761</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.774" sdnum="2052;">0.774</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Tang et al.[89]</td> <td align="left">Seglink++</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">PR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.829" sdnum="2052;">0.829</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.809" sdnum="2052;">0.809</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.815" sdnum="2052;">0.815</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.828" sdnum="2052;">0.828</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.798" sdnum="2052;">0.798</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.813" sdnum="2052;">0.813</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Wang et al. [92]</td> <td align="left">ContourNet</td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2020</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="0.869" sdnum="2052;">0.869</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.839" sdnum="2052;">0.839</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.854" sdnum="2052;">0.854</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.837" sdnum="2052;">0.837</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.841" sdnum="2052;">0.841</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.839" sdnum="2052;">0.839</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Zhang et al. [81]</td> <td align="left">LOMO</td> <td align="center"><font face="Arial">CVPR</font></td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;"><font face="Arial">2019</font></td> <td rowspan=5 align="center" valign=middle><font face="Arial">Hybrid</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.876</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.793</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.833</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.857</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.765</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.808</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">Xie et al.[61]</font></td> <td align="left" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">SPCNet</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">AAAI</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Times New Roman">2019</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">0.83</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> <td align="center" sdnum="2052;0;@"><font face="Arial">~</font></td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Xue et al.[85]</td> <td align="left">MSR</td> <td align="center">IJCAI</td> <td align="center" sdval="2019" sdnum="2052;">2019</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.852" sdnum="2052;">0.852</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.73" sdnum="2052;">0.73</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.768" sdnum="2052;">0.768</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.838" sdnum="2052;">0.838</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.778" sdnum="2052;">0.778</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.807" sdnum="2052;">0.807</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Liao et al. [91]</td> <td align="left">DB</td> <td align="center">AAAI</td> <td align="center" sdval="2020" sdnum="2052;">2020</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.871" sdnum="2052;">0.871</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.825" sdnum="2052;">0.825</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.847" sdnum="2052;">0.847</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.869" sdnum="2052;">0.869</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.802" sdnum="2052;">0.802</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.834" sdnum="2052;">0.834</td> </tr> <tr> <td height="20" align="left">Xiao et al.[93]</td> <td align="left">SDM</td> <td align="center">ECCV</td> <td align="center" sdval="2020" sdnum="2052;">2020</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.9085" sdnum="2052;">0.9085</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.8603" sdnum="2052;">0.8603</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.8837" sdnum="2052;">0.8837</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.884" sdnum="2052;">0.884</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.8442" sdnum="2052;">0.8442</td> <td align="center" sdval="0.8636" sdnum="2052;">0.8636</td> </tr> </table> <!-- ************************************************************************** --> </body>

<a id="3-survey"></a>

3. Survey

[A] [TPAMI-2015] Ye Q, Doermann D. Text detection and recognition in imagery: A survey[J]. IEEE transactions on pattern analysis and machine intelligence, 2015, 37(7): 1480-1500. paper

[B] [Frontiers-Comput. Sci-2016] Zhu Y, Yao C, Bai X. Scene text detection and recognition: Recent advances and future trends[J]. Frontiers of Computer Science, 2016, 10(1): 19-36. paper

[C] [arXiv-2018] Long S, He X, Ya C. Scene Text Detection and Recognition: The Deep Learning Era[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:1811.04256, 2018. paper

<a id="4-Evaluation"></a>

4. Evaluation

If you are insterested in developing better scene text detection metrics, some references recommended here might be useful.

[A] Wolf, Christian, and Jean-Michel Jolion. "Object count/area graphs for the evaluation of object detection and segmentation algorithms." International Journal of Document Analysis and Recognition (IJDAR) 8.4 (2006): 280-296. paper

[B] D. Karatzas, L. Gomez-Bigorda, A. Nicolaou, S. K. Ghosh, A. D.Bagdanov, M. Iwamura, J. Matas, L. Neumann, V. R. Chandrasekhar, S. Lu, F. Shafait, S. Uchida, and E. Valveny. ICDAR 2015 competition on robust reading. In ICDAR, pages 1156–1160, 2015. paper

[C] Calarasanu, Stefania, Jonathan Fabrizio, and Severine Dubuisson. "What is a good evaluation protocol for text localization systems? Concerns, arguments, comparisons and solutions." Image and Vision Computing 46 (2016): 1-17. paper

[D] Shi, Baoguang, et al. "ICDAR2017 competition on reading chinese text in the wild (RCTW-17)." 2017 14th IAPR International Conference on Document Analysis and Recognition (ICDAR). Vol. 1. IEEE, 2017. paper

[E] Nayef, N; Yin, F; Bizid, I; et al. ICDAR2017 robust reading challenge on multi-lingual scene text detection and script identification-rrc-mlt. In Document Analysis and Recognition (ICDAR), 2017 14th IAPR International Conference on, volume 1, 1454–1459. IEEE. paper

[F] Dangla, Aliona, et al. "A first step toward a fair comparison of evaluation protocols for text detection algorithms." 2018 13th IAPR International Workshop on Document Analysis Systems (DAS). IEEE, 2018. paper

[G] He,Mengchao and Liu, Yuliang, et al. ICPR2018 Contest on Robust Reading for Multi-Type Web images. ICPR 2018. paper

[H] Liu, Yuliang and Jin, Lianwen, et al. "Tightness-aware Evaluation Protocol for Scene Text Detection" Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). 2019. paper code

<a id="5-ocr-service"></a>

5. OCR Service

OCRAPIFree
Tesseract OCR Engine×
Azure
ABBYY
OCR Space
SODA PDF OCR
Free Online OCR
Online OCR
Super Tools
Online Chinese Recognition
Calamari OCR×
Tencent OCR×

<a id="6-references"></a>

6. References and Code

[1] Yao C, Bai X, Liu W, et al. Detecting texts of arbitrary orientations in natural images. 2012 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition(CVPR), 2012: 1083-1090. Paper
[2] Yin X C, Yin X, Huang K, et al. Robust text detection in natural scene images. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis & Machine Intelligence, 2013, 36(5): 970-83. Paper
[3] Li Y, Jia W, Shen C, et al. Characterness: An indicator of text in the wild. IEEE transactions on image processing, 2014, 23(4): 1666-1677. Paper
[4] Huang W, Qiao Y, Tang X. Robust scene text detection with convolution neural network induced mser trees. European Conference on Computer Vision(ECCV), 2014: 497-511. Paper
[5] Kang L, Li Y, Doermann D. Orientation robust text line detection in natural images. Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. 2014: 4034-4041. Paper
[6] Sun L, Huo Q, Jia W, et al. A robust approach for text detection from natural scene images. Pattern Recognition, 2015, 48(9): 2906-2920. Paper
[7] Yin X C, Pei W Y, Zhang J, et al. Multi-orientation scene text detection with adaptive clustering. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis & Machine Intelligence, 2015 (9): 1930-1937. Paper
[8] Liang G, Shivakumara P, Lu T, et al. Multi-spectral fusion based approach for arbitrarily oriented scene text detection in video images. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 2015, 24(11): 4488-4501. Paper
[9] Wu L, Shivakumara P, Lu T, et al. A New Technique for Multi-Oriented Scene Text Line Detection and Tracking in Video. IEEE Trans. Multimedia, 2015, 17(8): 1137-1152. Paper
[10] Zheng Z, Wei S, et al. Symmetry-based text line detection in natural scenes. IEEE Conference on Computer Vision & Pattern Recognition(CVPR), 2015. Paper
[11] Tian S, Pan Y, Huang C, et al. Text flow: A unified text detection system in natural scene images. Proceedings of the IEEE international conference on computer vision(ICCV). 2015: 4651-4659. Paper
[12] Buta M, et al. FASText: Efficient unconstrained scene text detector. 2015 IEEE International Conference on Computer Vision (ICCV). 2015: 1206-1214. Paper
[13] Tian Z, Huang W, He T, et al. Detecting text in natural image with connectionist text proposal network. European conference on computer vision(ECCV), 2016: 56-72. Paper Code
[14] Zhang Z, Zhang C, Shen W, et al. Multi-oriented text detection with fully convolutional networks. Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition(CVPR). 2016: 4159-4167. Paper
[15] Gupta A, Vedaldi A, Zisserman A. Synthetic data for text localisation in natural images. Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition(CVPR). 2016: 2315-2324. Paper Code
[16] S. Zhu and R. Zanibbi, A Text Detection System for Natural Scenes with Convolutional Feature Learning and Cascaded Classification, 2016 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), 2016: 625-632. Paper
[17] Tian S, Pei W Y, Zuo Z Y, et al. Scene Text Detection in Video by Learning Locally and Globally. IJCAI. 2016: 2647-2653. Paper
[18] He T, Huang W, Qiao Y, et al. Text-attentional convolutional neural network for scene text detection. IEEE transactions on image processing, 2016, 25(6): 2529-2541. Paper
[19] He, Dafang and Yang, Xiao and Huang, Wenyi and Zhou, Zihan and Kifer, Daniel and Giles, C Lee. Aggregating local context for accurate scene text detection. ACCV, 2016. Paper
[20] Zhong Z, Jin L, Zhang S, et al. Deeptext: A unified framework for text proposal generation and text detection in natural images. arXiv preprint arXiv:1605.07314, 2016. Paper
[21] Yao C, Bai X, Sang N, et al. Scene text detection via holistic, multi-channel prediction. arXiv preprint arXiv:1606.09002, 2016. Paper
[22] Liao M, Shi B, Bai X, et al. TextBoxes: A Fast Text Detector with a Single Deep Neural Network. AAAI. 2017: 4161-4167. Paper Code
[23] Shi B, Bai X, Belongie S. Detecting Oriented Text in Natural Images by Linking Segments. 2017 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2017: 3482-3490. Paper Code
[24] Zhou X, Yao C, Wen H, et al. EAST: an efficient and accurate scene text detector. CVPR, 2017: 2642-2651. Paper Code
[25] Liu Y, Jin L. Deep matching prior network: Toward tighter multi-oriented text detection. CVPR, 2017: 3454-3461. Paper
[26] He W, Zhang X Y, Yin F, et al. Deep Direct Regression for Multi-Oriented Scene Text Detection. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Computer Vision (ICCV). 2017: 745-753. Paper
[27] Hu H, Zhang C, Luo Y, et al. Wordsup: Exploiting word annotations for character based text detection. ICCV, 2017. Paper
[28] Wu Y, Natarajan P. Self-organized text detection with minimal post-processing via border learning. ICCV, 2017. Paper
[29] He P, Huang W, He T, et al. Single shot text detector with regional attention. The IEEE International Conference on Computer Vision (ICCV). 2017, 6(7). Paper Code
[30] Tian S, Lu S, Li C. Wetext: Scene text detection under weak supervision. ICCV, 2017. Paper
[31] Zhu, Xiangyu and Jiang, Yingying et al. Deep Residual Text Detection Network for Scene Text. ICDAR, 2017. Paper
[32] Tang Y , Wu X. Scene Text Detection and Segmentation Based on Cascaded Convolution Neural Networks. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 2017, 26(3):1509-1520. Paper
[33] Yang C, Yin X C, Pei W Y, et al. Tracking Based Multi-Orientation Scene Text Detection: A Unified Framework with Dynamic Programming. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 2017. Paper
[34] X. Ren, Y. Zhou, J. He, K. Chen, X. Yang and J. Sun, A Convolutional Neural Network-Based Chinese Text Detection Algorithm via Text Structure Modeling. in IEEE Transactions on Multimedia, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 506-518, March 2017. Paper
[35] Dai Y, Huang Z, Gao Y, et al. Fused text segmentation networks for multi-oriented scene text detection. arXiv preprint arXiv:1709.03272, 2017. Paper
[36] Jiang Y, Zhu X, Wang X, et al. R2CNN: rotational region CNN for orientation robust scene text detection. arXiv preprint arXiv:1706.09579, 2017. Paper
[37] Xing D, Li Z, Chen X, et al. ArbiText: Arbitrary-Oriented Text Detection in Unconstrained Scene. arXiv preprint arXiv:1711.11249, 2017. Paper
[38] C. Wang, F. Yin and C. Liu, Scene Text Detection with Novel Superpixel Based Character Candidate Extraction. in 2017 14th IAPR International Conference on Document Analysis and Recognition (ICDAR), 2017, pp. 929-934. Paper
[39] Sheng Zhang, Yuliang Liu, Lianwen Jin et al. Feature Enhancement Network: A Refined Scene Text Detector. In AAAI 2018. Paper
[40] Dan Deng et al. PixelLink: Detecting Scene Text via Instance Segmentation. In AAAI 2018. Paper Code
[41] Fangfang Wang, Liming Zhao, Xi L et al. Geometry-Aware Scene Text Detection with Instance Transformation Network. In CVPR 2018. Paper
[42] Zichuan Liu, Guosheng Lin, Sheng Yang et al. Learning Markov Clustering Networks for Scene Text Detection. In CVPR 2018. Paper
[43] Pengyuan Lyu, Cong Yao, Wenhao Wu et al. Multi-Oriented Scene Text Detection via Corner Localization and Region Segmentation. In CVPR 2018. Paper
[44] Minghui L, Zhen Z, Baoguang S. Rotation-Sensitive Regression for Oriented Scene Text Detection. In CVPR 2018. Paper
[45] Chuhui Xue et al. Accurate Scene Text Detection through Border Semantics Awareness and Bootstrapping. In ECCV 2018. Paper
[46] Long, Shangbang and Ruan, Jiaqiang, et al. TextSnake: A Flexible Representation for Detecting Text of Arbitrary Shapes. In ECCV, 2018. Paper
[47] Qiangpeng Yang, Mengli Cheng et al. IncepText: A New Inception-Text Module with Deformable PSROI Pooling for Multi-Oriented Scene Text Detection. In IJCAI 2018. Paper
[48] Xiaoyu Yue et al. Boosting up Scene Text Detectors with Guided CNN. In BMVC 2018. Paper
[49] Liao M, Shi B , Bai X. TextBoxes++: A Single-Shot Oriented Scene Text Detector. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 2018, 27(8):3676-3690. Paper Code
[50] W. He, X. Zhang, F. Yin and C. Liu, Multi-Oriented and Multi-Lingual Scene Text Detection With Direct Regression, in IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, vol. 27, no. 11, pp.5406-5419, 2018. Paper
[51] Ma J, Shao W, Ye H, et al. Arbitrary-oriented scene text detection via rotation proposals.in IEEE Transactions on Multimedia, 2018. Paper Code
[52] Youbao Tang and Xiangqian Wu. Scene Text Detection Using Superpixel-Based Stroke Feature Transform and Deep Learning Based Region Classification. In TMM, 2018. Paper
[53] Zhuoyao Zhong, Lei Sun and Qiang Huo. An Anchor-Free Region Proposal Network for Faster R-CNN based Text Detection Approaches. arXiv preprint arXiv:1804.09003. 2018. Paper
[54] Wenhai W, Enze X, et al. Shape Robust Text Detection with Progressive Scale Expansion Network. In CVPR 2019. Paper Code
[55] Zhu Y, Du J. Sliding Line Point Regression for Shape Robust Scene Text Detection. arXiv preprint arXiv:1801.09969, 2018. Paper
[56] Linjie D, Yanxiang Gong, et al. Detecting Multi-Oriented Text with Corner-based Region Proposals. arXiv preprint arXiv: 1804.02690, 2018. Paper Code
[57] Yongchao Xu, Yukang Wang, Wei Zhou, et al. TextField: Learning A Deep Direction Field for Irregular Scene Text Detection. arXiv preprint arXiv: 1812.01393, 2018. Paper
[58] Xiaowei Tian, Dao Wu, Rui Wang, Xiaochun Cao. Focal Text: an Accurate Text Detection with Focal Loss. In ICIP 2018. Paper
[59] Chenqin C, Pin L, Bing S. Feature Fusion Network for Scene Text Detection. In ICIP, 2018. Paper
[60] Sabyasachi Mohanty et al. Recurrent Global Convolutional Network for Scene Text Detection. In ICIP 2018. Paper
[61] Enze Xie, et al. Scene Text Detection with Supervised Pyramid Context Network. In AAAI 2019. Paper
[62] Youngmin Baek, Bado Lee, et al. Character Region Awareness for Text Detection. In CVPR 2019. Paper
[63] Yuliang L, Lianwen J, Shuaitao Z, et al. Curved Scene Text Detection via Transverse and Longitudinal Sequence Connection. Pattern Recognition, 2019. Paper Code
[64] Jingchao Liu, Xuebo Liu, et al, Pyramid Mask Text Detector. arXiv preprint arXiv:1903.11800, 2019. Paper Code
[79] Lele Xie, Yuliang Liu, Lianwen Jin, Zecheng Xie, DeRPN: Taking a further step toward more general object detection. In AAAI, 2019. Paper Code
[80] Yuliang Liu, Lianwen Jin, et al, Omnidirectional Scene Text Detction with Sequential-free Box Discretization. In IJCAI, 2019.Paper Code
[81] Chengquan Zhang, Borong Liang, et al, Look More Than Once: An Accurate Detector for Text of Arbitrary Shapes. In CVPR, 2019.Paper
[82] Xiaobing Wang, Yingying Jiang, et al, Arbitrary Shape Scene Text Detection with Adaptive Text Region Representation. In CVPR, 2019. Paper
[83] Zhuotao Tian, Michelle Shu, et al, Learning Shape-Aware Embedding for Scene Text Detection. In CVPR, 2019. Paper
[84] Zichuan Liu, Guosheng Lin, et al, Towards Robust Curve Text Detection with Conditional Spatial Expansion. In CVPR, 2019. Paper
[85] Xue C, Lu S, Zhang W. MSR: multi-scale shape regression for scene text detection. In IJCAI, 2019. Paper
[86] Wang Y, Xie H, Fu Z, et al. DSRN: a deep scale relationship network for scene text detection. In IJCAI, 2019: 947-953. Paper
[87] Elad Richardson, et al, It's All About The Scale -- Efficient Text Detection Using Adaptive Scaling. In WACV, 2020. Paper
[88] Pengfei Wang, et al, A Single-Shot Arbitrarily-Shaped Text Detector based on Context Attended Multi-Task Learning. In ACMM, 2019. Paper
[89] Jun Tang, et al, SegLink ++: Detecting Dense and Arbitrary-shaped Scene Text by Instance-aware Component Grouping. In PR, 2019. Paper
[90] Wenhai Wang, et al, Efficient and Accurate Arbitrary-Shaped Text Detection with Pixel Aggregation Network. In ICCV, 2019. Paper
[91] Minghui Liao, et al, Real-time Scene Text Detection with Differentiable Binarization. In AAAI, 2020. PaperCode
[92] Wang, Yuxin, et al. ContourNet: Taking a Further Step toward Accurate Arbitrary-shaped Scene Text Detection. CVPR. 2020. PaperCode
[93] Xiao, et al, Sequential Deformation for Accurate Scene Text Detection. In ECCV, 2020. Paper
                                                                                   Datasets
USTB-SV1K[65]:Xu-Cheng Yin, Xuwang Yin, Kaizhu Huang, and Hong-Wei Hao, Robust text detection in natural scene images, IEEE Trans. Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence (TPAMI), priprint, 2013. Paper
SVT[66]: Wang,Kai, and S. Belongie. Word Spotting in the Wild. European Conference on Computer Vision(ECCV), 2010: 591-604. Paper
ICDAR2005[67]: Lucas, S: ICDAR 2005 text locating competition results. In: ICDAR ,2005. Paper
ICDAR2011[68]: Shahab, A, Shafait, F, Dengel, A: ICDAR 2011 robust reading competition challenge 2: Reading text in scene images. In: ICDAR, 2011. Paper
ICDAR2013[69]:D. Karatzas, F. Shafait, S. Uchida, et al. ICDAR 2013 robust reading competition. In ICDAR, 2013. Paper
ICDAR2015[70]:D. Karatzas, L. Gomez-Bigorda, A. Nicolaou, S. K. Ghosh, A. D.Bagdanov, M. Iwamura, J. Matas, L. Neumann, V. R. Chandrasekhar, S. Lu, F. Shafait, S. Uchida, and E. Valveny. ICDAR 2015 competition on robust reading. In ICDAR, pages 1156–1160, 2015. Paper
MSRA-TD500[71]:C. Yao, X. Bai, W. Liu, Y. Ma, and Z. Tu, Detecting texts of arbitrary orientations in natural images. in Proc. IEEE Conf. Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, 2012, pp.1083–1090.Paper
COCO-Text[72]:Veit A, Matera T, Neumann L, et al. Coco-text: Dataset and benchmark for text detection and recognition in natural images. arXiv preprint arXiv:1601.07140, 2016. Paper
RCTW-17[73]:Shi B, Yao C, Liao M, et al. ICDAR2017 competition on reading chinese text in the wild (RCTW-17). Document Analysis and Recognition (ICDAR), 2017 14th IAPR International Conference on. IEEE, 2017, 1: 1429-1434. Paper
Total-Text[74]:Chee C K, Chan C S. Total-text: A comprehensive dataset for scene text detection and recognition.Document Analysis and Recognition (ICDAR), 2017 14th IAPR International Conference on. IEEE, 2017, 1: 935-942.Paper
SCUT-CTW1500[75]:Yuliang L, Lianwen J, Shuaitao Z, et al. Curved Scene Text Detection via Transverse and Longitudinal Sequence Connection. Pattern Recognition, 2019.Paper
MLT 2017[76]: Nayef, N; Yin, F; Bizid, I; et al. ICDAR2017 robust reading challenge on multi-lingual scene text detection and script identification-rrc-mlt. In Document Analysis and Recognition (ICDAR), 2017 14th IAPR International Conference on, volume 1, 1454–1459. IEEE. Paper
OSTD[77]: Chucai Yi and YingLi Tian, Text string detection from natural scenes by structure-based partition and grouping, In IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, vol. 20, no. 9, pp. 2594–2605, 2011. Paper
CTW[78]: Yuan T L, Zhu Z, Xu K, et al. Chinese Text in the Wild. arXiv preprint arXiv:1803.00085, 2018. Paper

If you find any problems in our resources, or any good papers/codes we have missed, please inform us at liuchongyu1996@gmail.com. Thank you for your contribution.

Copyright

Copyright © 2019 SCUT-DLVC. All Rights Reserved.

<p align="center"> <img src="scut-dlvc.jpeg" alt="Sample" width="150" height="75"> <p align="center"> <em></em> </p> </p>