Home

Awesome

TF Keras YOLOv4/v3/v2 Modelset

license

Introduction

A general YOLOv4/v3/v2 object detection pipeline inherited from keras-yolo3-Mobilenet/keras-yolo3 and YAD2K. Implement with tf.keras, including data collection/annotation, model training/tuning, model evaluation and on device deployment. Support different architecture and different technologies:

Backbone

Head

Loss

Postprocess

Train tech

On-device deployment

Quick Start

  1. Install requirements on Ubuntu 16.04/18.04:
# apt install python3-opencv imagemagick
# pip install Cython
# pip install -r requirements.txt
  1. Download Related Darknet/YOLOv2/v3/v4 weights from YOLO website and AlexeyAB/darknet.
  2. Convert the Darknet YOLO model to a Keras model.
  3. Run YOLO detection on your image or video, default using Tiny YOLOv3 model.
# wget -O weights/darknet53.conv.74.weights https://pjreddie.com/media/files/darknet53.conv.74
# wget -O weights/darknet19_448.conv.23.weights https://pjreddie.com/media/files/darknet19_448.conv.23
# wget -O weights/yolov3.weights https://pjreddie.com/media/files/yolov3.weights
# wget -O weights/yolov3-tiny.weights https://pjreddie.com/media/files/yolov3-tiny.weights
# wget -O weights/yolov3-spp.weights https://pjreddie.com/media/files/yolov3-spp.weights
# wget -O weights/yolov2.weights http://pjreddie.com/media/files/yolo.weights
# wget -O weights/yolov2-voc.weights http://pjreddie.com/media/files/yolo-voc.weights
# wget -O weights/yolov2-tiny.weights https://pjreddie.com/media/files/yolov2-tiny.weights
# wget -O weights/yolov2-tiny-voc.weights https://pjreddie.com/media/files/yolov2-tiny-voc.weights

### manually download csdarknet53-omega_final.weights from https://drive.google.com/open?id=18jCwaL4SJ-jOvXrZNGHJ5yz44g9zi8Hm
# wget -O weights/yolov4.weights https://github.com/AlexeyAB/darknet/releases/download/darknet_yolo_v3_optimal/yolov4.weights

# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/yolov3.cfg weights/yolov3.weights weights/yolov3.h5
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/yolov3-tiny.cfg weights/yolov3-tiny.weights weights/yolov3-tiny.h5
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/yolov3-spp.cfg weights/yolov3-spp.weights weights/yolov3-spp.h5
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/yolov2.cfg weights/yolov2.weights weights/yolov2.h5
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/yolov2-voc.cfg weights/yolov2-voc.weights weights/yolov2-voc.h5
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/yolov2-tiny.cfg weights/yolov2-tiny.weights weights/yolov2-tiny.h5
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/yolov2-tiny-voc.cfg weights/yolov2-tiny-voc.weights weights/yolov2-tiny-voc.h5
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/darknet53.cfg weights/darknet53.conv.74.weights weights/darknet53.h5
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/darknet19_448_body.cfg weights/darknet19_448.conv.23.weights weights/darknet19.h5

# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/csdarknet53-omega.cfg weights/csdarknet53-omega_final.weights weights/cspdarknet53.h5

### make sure to reorder output tensors for YOLOv4 cfg and weights file
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py --yolo4_reorder cfg/yolov4.cfg weights/yolov4.weights weights/yolov4.h5

### Scaled YOLOv4
### manually download yolov4-csp.weights from https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NQwz47cW0NUgy7L3_xOKaNEfLoQuq3EL/view?usp=sharing
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py --yolo4_reorder cfg/yolov4-csp_fixed.cfg weights/yolov4-csp.weights weights/scaled-yolov4-csp.h5

### Yolo-Fastest
# wget -O weights/yolo-fastest.weights https://github.com/dog-qiuqiu/Yolo-Fastest/raw/master/ModelZoo/yolo-fastest-1.0_coco/yolo-fastest.weights
# wget -O weights/yolo-fastest-xl.weights https://github.com/dog-qiuqiu/Yolo-Fastest/raw/master/ModelZoo/yolo-fastest-1.0_coco/yolo-fastest-xl.weights

# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/yolo-fastest.cfg weights/yolo-fastest.weights weights/yolo-fastest.h5
# python tools/model_converter/convert.py cfg/yolo-fastest-xl.cfg weights/yolo-fastest-xl.weights weights/yolo-fastest-xl.h5


# python yolo.py --image
# python yolo.py --input=<your video file>

For other model, just do in a similar way, but specify different model type, weights path and anchor path with --model_type, --weights_path and --anchors_path.

Image detection sample:

<p align="center"> <img src="assets/dog_inference.jpg"> <img src="assets/kite_inference.jpg"> </p>

Guide of train/evaluate/demo

Train

  1. Generate train/val/test annotation file and class names file.

    Data annotation file format:

    • One row for one image in annotation file;
    • Row format: image_file_path box1 box2 ... boxN;
    • Box format: x_min,y_min,x_max,y_max,class_id (no space).
    • Here is an example:
    path/to/img1.jpg 50,100,150,200,0 30,50,200,120,3
    path/to/img2.jpg 120,300,250,600,2
    ...
    
    1. For VOC style dataset, you can use voc_annotation.py to convert original dataset to our annotation file:

      # cd tools/dataset_converter/ && python voc_annotation.py -h
      usage: voc_annotation.py [-h] [--dataset_path DATASET_PATH] [--year YEAR]
                               [--set SET] [--output_path OUTPUT_PATH]
                               [--classes_path CLASSES_PATH] [--include_difficult]
                               [--include_no_obj]
      
      convert PascalVOC dataset annotation to txt annotation file
      
      optional arguments:
        -h, --help            show this help message and exit
        --dataset_path DATASET_PATH
                              path to PascalVOC dataset, default is ../../VOCdevkit
        --year YEAR           subset path of year (2007/2012), default will cover
                              both
        --set SET             convert data set, default will cover train, val and
                              test
        --output_path OUTPUT_PATH
                              output path for generated annotation txt files,
                              default is ./
        --classes_path CLASSES_PATH
                              path to class definitions
        --include_difficult   to include difficult object
        --include_no_obj      to include no object image
      

      By default, the VOC convert script will try to go through both VOC2007/VOC2012 dataset dir under the dataset_path and generate train/val/test annotation file separately, like:

      2007_test.txt  2007_train.txt  2007_val.txt  2012_train.txt  2012_val.txt
      

      You can merge these train & val annotation file as your need. For example, following cmd will creat 07/12 combined trainval dataset:

      # cp 2007_train.txt trainval.txt
      # cat 2007_val.txt >> trainval.txt
      # cat 2012_train.txt >> trainval.txt
      # cat 2012_val.txt >> trainval.txt
      

      P.S. You can use LabelImg to annotate your object detection dataset with Pascal VOC XML format

    2. For COCO style dataset, you can use coco_annotation.py to convert original dataset to our annotation file:

      # cd tools/dataset_converter/ && python coco_annotation.py -h
      usage: coco_annotation.py [-h] [--dataset_path DATASET_PATH]
                                [--output_path OUTPUT_PATH]
                                [--classes_path CLASSES_PATH] [--include_no_obj]
                                [--customize_coco]
      
      convert COCO dataset annotation to txt annotation file
      
      optional arguments:
        -h, --help            show this help message and exit
        --dataset_path DATASET_PATH
                              path to MSCOCO dataset, default is ../../mscoco2017
        --output_path OUTPUT_PATH
                              output path for generated annotation txt files,
                              default is ./
        --classes_path CLASSES_PATH
                              path to class definitions, default is
                              ../configs/coco_classes.txt
        --include_no_obj      to include no object image
        --customize_coco      It is a user customize coco dataset. Will not follow
                              standard coco class label
      

      This script will try to convert COCO instances_train2017 and instances_val2017 under dataset_path. You can change the code for your dataset

    If you want to download PascalVOC or COCO dataset, refer to Dockerfile for cmd

    For class names file format, refer to coco_classes.txt

    After dataset is ready, you can manually review it with dataset_visualize.py

  2. If you're training YOLOv4/v3/v2 models with Darknet based backbones, make sure you have converted pretrain model weights as in Quick Start part

  3. train.py

# python train.py -h
usage: train.py [-h] [--model_type MODEL_TYPE] [--anchors_path ANCHORS_PATH]
                [--model_input_shape MODEL_INPUT_SHAPE]
                [--weights_path WEIGHTS_PATH]
                [--annotation_file ANNOTATION_FILE]
                [--val_annotation_file VAL_ANNOTATION_FILE]
                [--val_split VAL_SPLIT] [--classes_path CLASSES_PATH]
                [--batch_size BATCH_SIZE] [--optimizer {adam,rmsprop,sgd}]
                [--learning_rate LEARNING_RATE]
                [--average_type {None,ema,swa,lookahead}]
                [--decay_type {None,cosine,exponential,polynomial,piecewise_constant}]
                [--transfer_epoch TRANSFER_EPOCH]
                [--freeze_level {None,0,1,2}] [--init_epoch INIT_EPOCH]
                [--total_epoch TOTAL_EPOCH] [--multiscale]
                [--rescale_interval RESCALE_INTERVAL]
                [--enhance_augment {None,mosaic}]
                [--label_smoothing LABEL_SMOOTHING] [--multi_anchor_assign]
                [--elim_grid_sense] [--data_shuffle] [--gpu_num GPU_NUM]
                [--model_pruning] [--eval_online]
                [--eval_epoch_interval EVAL_EPOCH_INTERVAL]
                [--save_eval_checkpoint]

optional arguments:
  -h, --help            show this help message and exit
  --model_type MODEL_TYPE
                        YOLO model type: yolo3_mobilenet_lite/tiny_yolo3_mobil
                        enet/yolo3_darknet/..., default=yolo3_mobilenet_lite
  --anchors_path ANCHORS_PATH
                        path to anchor definitions,
                        default=configs/yolo3_anchors.txt
  --model_input_shape MODEL_INPUT_SHAPE
                        Initial model image input shape as <height>x<width>,
                        default=416x416
  --weights_path WEIGHTS_PATH
                        Pretrained model/weights file for fine tune
  --annotation_file ANNOTATION_FILE
                        train annotation txt file, default=trainval.txt
  --val_annotation_file VAL_ANNOTATION_FILE
                        val annotation txt file, default=None
  --val_split VAL_SPLIT
                        validation data persentage in dataset if no val
                        dataset provide, default=0.1
  --classes_path CLASSES_PATH
                        path to class definitions,
                        default=configs/voc_classes.txt
  --batch_size BATCH_SIZE
                        Batch size for train, default=16
  --optimizer {adam,rmsprop,sgd}
                        optimizer for training (adam/rmsprop/sgd),
                        default=adam
  --learning_rate LEARNING_RATE
                        Initial learning rate, default=0.001
  --average_type {None,ema,swa,lookahead}
                        weights average type, default=None
  --decay_type {None,cosine,exponential,polynomial,piecewise_constant}
                        Learning rate decay type, default=None
  --transfer_epoch TRANSFER_EPOCH
                        Transfer training (from Imagenet) stage epochs,
                        default=10
  --freeze_level {None,0,1,2}
                        Freeze level of the model in transfer training stage.
                        0:NA/1:backbone/2:only open prediction layer
  --init_epoch INIT_EPOCH
                        Initial training epochs for fine tune training,
                        default=0
  --total_epoch TOTAL_EPOCH
                        Total training epochs, default=250
  --multiscale          Whether to use multiscale training
  --rescale_interval RESCALE_INTERVAL
                        Number of iteration(batches) interval to rescale input
                        size, default=10
  --enhance_augment {None,mosaic}
                        enhance data augmentation type (None/mosaic),
                        default=None
  --label_smoothing LABEL_SMOOTHING
                        Label smoothing factor (between 0 and 1) for
                        classification loss, default=0
  --multi_anchor_assign
                        Assign multiple anchors to single ground truth
  --elim_grid_sense     Eliminate grid sensitivity
  --data_shuffle        Whether to shuffle train/val data for cross-validation
  --gpu_num GPU_NUM     Number of GPU to use, default=1
  --model_pruning       Use model pruning for optimization, only for TF 1.x
  --eval_online         Whether to do evaluation on validation dataset during
                        training
  --eval_epoch_interval EVAL_EPOCH_INTERVAL
                        Number of iteration(epochs) interval to do evaluation,
                        default=10
  --save_eval_checkpoint
                        Whether to save checkpoint with best evaluation result

NOTE: if enable --elim_grid_sense feature during training, recommended to also use it in following demo/inference step.

Following is a reference training config cmd:

# python train.py --model_type=yolo3_mobilenet_lite --anchors_path=configs/yolo3_anchors.txt --annotation_file=trainval.txt --classes_path=configs/voc_classes.txt --eval_online --save_eval_checkpoint

Checkpoints during training could be found at logs/000/. Choose a best one as result

You can also use Tensorboard to monitor the loss trend during train:

# tensorboard --logdir=logs/000

MultiGPU usage: use --gpu_num N to use N GPUs. It use tf.distribute.MirroredStrategy to support MultiGPU environment.

Loss type couldn't be changed from CLI options. You can try them by changing params in loss.py(v3) or loss.py(v2)

Postprocess type (SoftNMS/DIoU-NMS/Cluster-NMS/WBF) could be configured in yolo_postprocess_np.py

Model dump

We need to dump out inference model from training checkpoint for eval or demo. Following script cmd work for that.

# python yolo.py --model_type=yolo3_mobilenet_lite --weights_path=logs/000/<checkpoint>.h5 --anchors_path=configs/yolo3_anchors.txt --classes_path=configs/voc_classes.txt --model_input_shape=416x416 --dump_model --output_model_file=model.h5

Change model_type, anchors file & class file for different training mode. If --model_pruning was added in training, you also need to use --pruning_model here for dumping out the pruned model.

NOTE: Now you can dump out a non-square input shape (e.g. using --model_input_shape=320x416) model and do inference as normal, but the input height & weights must be multiples of 32.

Evaluation

Use eval.py to do evaluation on the inference model with your test data. It support following metrics:

  1. Pascal VOC mAP: will generate txt detection result result/detection_result.txt, draw rec/pre curve for each class and AP/mAP result chart in "result" dir with default 0.5 IOU or specified IOU, and optionally save all the detection result on evaluation dataset as images

  2. MS COCO AP. will generate txt detection result, draw overall AP chart and AP on different scale (small, medium, large) as COCO standard. It can also optionally save all the detection result

# python eval.py --model_path=model.h5 --anchors_path=configs/yolo3_anchors.txt --classes_path=configs/voc_classes.txt --model_input_shape=416x416 --eval_type=VOC --iou_threshold=0.5 --conf_threshold=0.001 --annotation_file=2007_test.txt --save_result

If you're evaluating with MSCOCO dataset, you can further use pycoco_eval.py with the generated txt detection result and COCO GT annotation to get official COCO AP with pycocotools:

# cd tools/evaluation/ && python pycoco_eval.py -h
usage: pycoco_eval.py [-h] --result_txt RESULT_TXT --coco_annotation_json
                      COCO_ANNOTATION_JSON
                      [--coco_result_json COCO_RESULT_JSON] [--customize_coco]

generate coco result json and evaluate COCO AP with pycocotools

optional arguments:
  -h, --help            show this help message and exit
  --result_txt RESULT_TXT
                        txt detection result file
  --coco_annotation_json COCO_ANNOTATION_JSON
                        coco json annotation file
  --coco_result_json COCO_RESULT_JSON
                        output coco json result file, default is
                        ./coco_result.json
  --customize_coco      It is a user customize coco dataset. Will not follow
                        standard coco class label

# python pycoco_eval.py --result_txt=../../result/detection_result.txt --coco_annotation_json=./instances_val2017.json --coco_result_json=coco_result.json

You can use tide_eval.py with the output COCO json result and COCO GT annotation for detection errors analysis. It's proposed and supported by tide:

# cd tools/evaluation/ && python tide_eval.py -h
usage: tide_eval.py [-h] --coco_annotation_json COCO_ANNOTATION_JSON
                    --coco_result_json COCO_RESULT_JSON

evaluate TIDE dAP with tidecv

optional arguments:
  -h, --help            show this help message and exit
  --coco_annotation_json COCO_ANNOTATION_JSON
                        coco json annotation file
  --coco_result_json COCO_RESULT_JSON
                        coco json result file

# python tide_eval.py --coco_annotation_json=./instances_val2017.json --coco_result_json=coco_result.json

P.S. for VOC style dataset, we also provide pascal_voc_to_coco.py to generate COCO GT annotation.

If you enable --eval_online option in train.py, a default Pascal VOC mAP evaluation on validation dataset will be executed during training. But that may cost more time for train process.

Following is a sample result trained on Mobilenet YOLOv3 Lite model with PascalVOC dataset (using a reasonable score threshold=0.1):

<p align="center"> <img src="assets/mAP.jpg"> <img src="assets/COCO_AP.jpg"> </p>

Some experiment on MSCOCO dataset and comparison:

Model nameInputSizeTrainSetTestSetCOCO APPascal mAP@.5FLOPSParamSizeSpeedPs
YOLOv3 Lite-Mobilenet320x320train2017val201719.4038.584.76G8.09M32MB14.6msKeras on Titan XP
YOLOv3 Lite-Mobilenet416x416train2017val201722.6943.618.04G8.09M32MB16.9msKeras on Titan XP
Tiny YOLOv3 Lite-Mobilenet320x320train2017val201716.4134.173.04G5.19M21MB8.7msKeras on Titan XP
Tiny YOLOv3 Lite-Mobilenet416x416train2017val201719.2839.365.13G5.19M21MB9.3msKeras on Titan XP
YOLOv3-Xception608x608train2017val201727.1451.89209.53G105.37M403MB56msKeras on Titan XP
YOLOv4-Efficientnet(B1)512x512train2017val201733.4356.1462.74G65.72M253MB44msKeras on Titan XP
ssd_mobilenet_v1_coco600x600COCO trainCOCO val2128MB30msTF on Titan X
ssdlite_mobilenet_v2_coco600x600COCO trainCOCO val2219MB27msTF on Titan X

Some experiment on PascalVOC dataset and comparison:

Model nameInputSizeTrainSetTestSetmAPFLOPSParamSizeSpeedPs
YOLOv4-Efficientnet(B1)512x512VOC07+12VOC0782.39%62.02G65.32M251MB44msKeras on Titan XP
Tiny YOLOv3 Lite-MobilenetV3Small416x416VOC07+12VOC0765.09%731.64M1.50M6.5MB110msMNN on ARM Cortex-A53 * 4
YOLOv3 Lite-Mobilenet320x320VOC07+12VOC0773.47%4.51G7.77M31.8MB17msKeras on Titan XP
YOLOv3 Lite-Mobilenet416x416VOC07+12VOC0776.55%7.60G7.77M31.8MB20msKeras on Titan XP
YOLOv3 Lite-SPP-Mobilenet416x416VOC07+12VOC0776.32%7.98G8.81M34MB22msKeras on Titan XP
YOLOv3 Lite-PeleeNet416x416VOC07+12VOC0778.07%6.60G4.92M21MB33msKeras on Titan XP
Tiny YOLOv3 Lite-Mobilenet320x320VOC07+12VOC0769.10%2.93G4.92M20.1MB9msKeras on Titan XP
Tiny YOLOv3 Lite-Mobilenet416x416VOC07+12VOC0772.90%4.95G4.92M20.1MB11msKeras on Titan XP
Tiny YOLOv3 Lite-Mobilenet with GIoU loss416x416VOC07+12VOC0772.92%4.95G4.92M20.1MB11msKeras on Titan XP
YOLOv3 Nano416x416VOC07+12VOC0769.55%6.40G4.66M19MB29msKeras on Titan XP
YOLOv3-Xception512x512VOC07+12VOC0779.15%147.30G104.72M419.8MB48msKeras on Titan XP
YOLOv3-Mobilenet320x320VOC07VOC0764.22%29fpsKeras on 1080Ti
YOLOv3-Mobilenet320x320VOC07+12VOC0774.56%29fpsKeras on 1080Ti
YOLOv3-Mobilenet416x416VOC07+12VOC0776.82%25fpsKeras on 1080Ti
MobileNet-SSD300x300VOC07+12+cocoVOC0772.7%22MB
MobileNet-SSD300x300VOC07+12VOC0768%22MB
Faster RCNN, VGG-16~1000x600VOC07+12VOC0773.2%151msCaffe on Titan X
SSD,VGG-16300x300VOC07+12VOC0777.5%201MB39fpsKeras on Titan X

NOTE:

  1. mAP/AP is evaluated with "Weighted-Distance-Cluster-NMS" post process, which has better performance than Traditional NMS

  2. If you meet any model loading problem with these pretrained weights due to h5 format compatibility issue, try to run "Model dump" with it again to regenerate the inference model.

Demo

  1. yolo.py

image detection mode

# python yolo.py --model_type=yolo3_mobilenet_lite --weights_path=model.h5 --anchors_path=configs/yolo3_anchors.txt --classes_path=configs/voc_classes.txt --model_input_shape=416x416 --image

video detection mode

# python yolo.py --model_type=yolo3_mobilenet_lite --weights_path=model.h5 --anchors_path=configs/yolo3_anchors.txt --classes_path=configs/voc_classes.txt --model_input_shape=416x416 --input=test.mp4

For video detection mode, you can use --input=0 to capture live video from web camera and --output=<video name> to dump out detection result to another video

Tensorflow model convert

Using keras_to_tensorflow.py to convert the tf.keras .h5 model to tensorflow frozen pb model:

# python keras_to_tensorflow.py
    --input_model="path/to/keras/model.h5"
    --output_model="path/to/save/model.pb"

ONNX model convert

Using keras_to_onnx.py to convert the tf.keras .h5 model to ONNX model:

### need to set environment TF_KERAS=1 for tf.keras model
# export TF_KERAS=1
# python keras_to_onnx.py
    --keras_model_file="path/to/keras/model.h5"
    --output_file="path/to/save/model.onnx"
    --op_set=11

by default, the converted ONNX model follows TF NHWC layout. You can also use --inputs_as_nchw to convert input layout to NCHW, and use onnx_edit.py to edit generated ONNX model to convert output layout to NCHW.

You can also use eval.py to do evaluation on the pb & onnx inference model

Inference model deployment

See on-device inference for TFLite & MNN model deployment

TODO

Some issues to know

  1. The test environment is

    • Ubuntu 16.04/18.04
    • Python 3.6.8
    • tensorflow 2.0.0/tensorflow 1.15.0
    • tf.keras 2.2.4-tf
  2. Default YOLOv4/v3/v2 anchors are used. If you want to use your own anchors, probably some changes are needed. kmeans.py or kmeans_evolve.py could be used to do K-Means anchor clustering on your dataset

  3. Imagenet pretrained weights for backbone is automatically loaded when training, so recommended to freeze backbone layers for several epochs in transfer traning stage.

  4. Training strategy is for reference only. Adjust it according to your dataset and your goal. And add further strategy if needed.

Contribution guidelines

New features, improvements and any other kind of contributions are warmly welcome via pull request :)

Citation

Please cite keras-YOLOv3-model-set in your publications if it helps your research:

@article{MobileNet-Yolov3,
     Author = {Adam Yang},
     Year = {2018}
}
@article{keras-yolo3,
     Author = {qqwweee},
     Year = {2018}
}
@article{YAD2K,
     title={YAD2K: Yet Another Darknet 2 Keras},
     Author = {allanzelener},
     Year = {2017}
}
@article{yolov4,
     title={YOLOv4: Optimal Speed and Accuracy of Object Detection},
     author={Alexey Bochkovskiy, Chien-Yao Wang, Hong-Yuan Mark Liao},
     journal = {arXiv},
     year={2020}
}
@article{yolov3,
     title={YOLOv3: An Incremental Improvement},
     author={Redmon, Joseph and Farhadi, Ali},
     journal = {arXiv},
     year={2018}
}
@article{redmon2016yolo9000,
  title={YOLO9000: Better, Faster, Stronger},
  author={Redmon, Joseph and Farhadi, Ali},
  journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:1612.08242},
  year={2016}
}
@article{Focal Loss,
     title={Focal Loss for Dense Object Detection},
     author={Tsung-Yi Lin, Priya Goyal, Ross Girshick, Kaiming He, Piotr Dollár},
     journal = {arXiv},
     year={2017}
}
@article{GIoU,
     title={Generalized Intersection over Union: A Metric and A Loss for Bounding Box Regression},
     author={Hamid Rezatofighi, Nathan Tsoi1, JunYoung Gwak1, Amir Sadeghian, Ian Reid, Silvio Savarese},
     journal = {arXiv},
     year={2019}
}
@article{DIoU Loss,
     title={Distance-IoU Loss: Faster and Better Learning for Bounding Box Regression},
     author={Zhaohui Zheng, Ping Wang, Wei Liu, Jinze Li, Rongguang Ye, Dongwei Ren},
     journal = {arXiv},
     year={2020}
}
@inproceedings{tide-eccv2020,
  author    = {Daniel Bolya and Sean Foley and James Hays and Judy Hoffman},
  title     = {TIDE: A General Toolbox for Identifying Object Detection Errors},
  booktitle = {ECCV},
  year      = {2020},
}